When choosing a crib mattress for your baby, it might seem overwhelming knowing which one you should choose.
Should you go for the one for your friend or neighbor recommended? Or the one that you see advertised on Facebook for being the number one crib mattress?
Your baby will spend a lot of time in their crib, especially considering how much they will be sleeping during the night or napping (Spoiler alert: babies sleep up to 18 hours a day), so it is worth taking the time to weigh your options.
We have compiled some tips for choosing the right crib mattress, what to look for, as well as highlighting one particular mattress brand and similar options: The Sealy Crib Mattress Line.
The Sealy Crib Mattress Line
Sealy Crib Mattresses are designed with quality and safety in mind. The Sealy name has been trusted by parents since 1881 to provide the highest quality mattresses for their babies and children.
Here are a few of the top mattresses offered in the Sealy line, as well as their features:
This keeps the crib mattress clean and dry and can help prevent stains and prevent moisture and mildew from entering the mattress.
The mattress can also be wiped down with a damp cloth. One thing to consider about waterproof coverings is that they can sometimes feel cool to the touch, so you will want to ensure your baby has extra warmth when sleeping.
Contains 150 durability-tested innerspring coils provide secure support
Steal Border Rods
Provide maximum safety and support around the perimeter of the bed to ensure babies or toddlers will not fall out.
Fits toddler bed frames for an easy transition when it is time.
Passed safety tests for proper crib fit and sizing, as well as air quality tested (made without lead and phthalates).
- Contains no harmful chemicals.
Certified Gold Standard, which is a strict test for children’s products, with various ranges of safety and health concerns.
- 150 COIL COUNT -- Engineered with 150 extra firm heat-tempered interlocking steel coils for long-lasting support and secure-edge heavy gauge steel border rods, providing maximum support around the sides of baby's mattress.
- WATERPROOF SURFACE & COMFORTABLE LAYERS -- Reinforced cover with lock-stitched waterproof binding resists stains, odors and moisture. Firm hypoallergenic layers provide a hypoallergenic sleeping layer for comfort and support.
- SAFETY & QUALITY TESTED -- Firmness, durability and crib fit tested, passes American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) Crib Mattress Standards, this entire crib mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified for indoor air quality and tested for chemicals to help create a healthier sleeping environment for your baby. Meets or exceeds all flammability, lead, phthalate and CPSIA testing and does not contain toxic fire retardants.
- FITS CRIBS & TODDLER BED FRAMES -- Fits snugly in cribs and also fits toddler bed frames. Beds, Bed frames and Foundations sold separately.
- WARRANTY -- Lifetime warranty on workmanship and materials.
Airflow pockets help keep the mattress fresh and ventilated without using any metal parts – This is important because when a mattress is waterproof, it does not always “breathe” properly, so these help to keep the mattress ventilated.
Contains two hypoallergenic layers on each side of the mattress to keep mold and mildew out and provide posture support.
Secure borders around edges to keep baby safe
Contains no harmful chemicals and is certified Gold Standard
Offers more support and durability in comparison to other mattress models.
Fits toddler bed frames for an easy transition when it is time.
Contains no harmful chemicals.
Sealy Mattress Firmness
Sealy uses innerspring coil designs for all their crib mattresses because you do not want to have a crib mattress that is too soft.
When babies are born, their bones are still in a developing stage and babies lack mobility and it will take time for them to learn to adjust their sleeping position as necessary.
A firm mattress ensure that they have a surface to lean on as they learn to roll over onto their tummies or lay on their side.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends that if you press on the mattress firmly with your hand, it should pop back up quickly, without contouring the shape of your hand.
Babies need this firmness, especially in the beginning because it is important for their early development.
If the mattress feels soft and cushiony to you, it is most likely too soft for your newborn baby and a firmer mattress should be selected.
A mattress that is too soft will have edges and divots where babies can get their arms or legs stuck and could risk suffocation or serious injury due to getting stuck on these sections.
For their safety, please remember to take this into consideration when crib mattress shopping.
What to Look for in a Crib Mattress
There are certain features and aspects you want to look for in a crib mattress, as you want to be sure it will be a good fit for your baby and potentially your toddler if you transition your baby to it.
Sleep is crucial for your baby’s growth and development, so it is vital that you properly plan out his or her sleeping environment carefully.
Here are some tips on what to look for:
While plastic mattresses or hand-me-downs may be cheaper and easier to find, they will also crack more easily or dry out over time.
They are not comfortable for baby to sleep on if they are noisy and damaged.
Mattresses such as the Sealy Crib Mattress contain innersprings that will help provide more orthopedic support and are puncture-resistant.
Typically, a good rule of thumb is that if the mattress is heavier and denser, it is a higher quality mattress.
If it feels light as a feather or like you could throw it across the room easily, it is probably not a very high-quality mattress.
Now, this does not mean that you have to spend an arm and a leg on a mattress, but you can find a high-quality mattress starting around $90.
What Matters is on the Inside
When checking out different mattresses, make sure you read about what is inside the mattress, rather than what type of cushioning or covering it has.
You will want to ensure that it has interior frame support so you it will provide the proper firmness to keep your baby safe and secure.
Foam mattresses can also be safe, but just be aware of how durable it is and how it is made.
Buy it New
While getting items secondhand when you have a baby can be a lifesaver, approach this with caution when it comes to mattresses and other items.
When you buy a mattress secondhand or receive one from a friend or family member, you do not always know how it was stored, cared for, or how long it was used for.
Mold can grow inside mattresses, depending on how much liquids they are exposed to or what type of materials the mattress is made from.
Therefore, the Sealy Crib Mattress is an excellent choice because it keeps mold and other liquids out.
One eye-opening study linked secondhand crib mattresses and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome or SIDS, so please be careful when considering purchasing a crib mattress secondhand.
Find the Right Fit
Crib mattresses must be large enough to fit inside a crib to ensure the mattress does not slide around and that the baby cannot get stuck in the crack between the mattress and the crib.
The Federal government regulates the size for standard crib mattresses, via the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008. The minimum size is 27 1/4” x 51 5/8” with a thickness not exceeding 6 inches.
Make sure you test it in the crib you are planning to use, as well. The general guideline is that if you can squeeze more than two fingers between the mattress and the crib, you will need a larger mattress.
Buy a Mattress Cover
Even if you purchase a mattress, such as the Sealy Crib Mattress, that states that it is waterproof or water resistant, it is always a good idea to invest in a high-quality mattress cover.
This will help protect the mattress from stains and will help make your baby’s sleeping surface more comfortable and cozy, as waterproof mattress tops can get cold to the touch.
Mattress covers can also be machine washed when inevitable diaper leaks happen.
Test it Out
Before you commit to purchasing a new crib mattress, make sure you test it out to make sure it not only fits your crib frame or bed frame, but that it will be the right fit for your lifestyle.
If you find that it is difficult to clean or that your baby does not seem comfortable on the mattress, find out if the retailer or store where you purchased the bed will accept a return or exchange for a better fit.
Many retailers offer a 30-day money back guarantee, where you can try out a product and return it if you are not fully satisfied.
Do not worry, however, about finding the best and longest warranty for a mattress, especially if it costs extra to add it.
If you are paying for a high-quality mattress, such as the Sealy Crib Mattress, you will not need to worry about running into issues.
With the right care and storage, a crib mattress should last up until you transition it to a toddler bed without any issues and you will most likely not need a long-lasting warranty.
You can find a Sealy retailer here.
Check for Certifications
All crib mattresses in the United States must meet very specific safety standards by various organizations, but there are other certifications you can look for to ensure even further safety and testing.
For instance, if you are looking for an organic, eco-friendly crib mattress, make sure to look for a certification stating “100 percent organic”, as well as the group that is certifying it.
A common organization that certifies organic products is The Environmental Working Group.
Another common organization that issues Gold standard certifications for mattresses is Greenguard, which ensures all products pass all necessary state and federal regulations, as well as testing for various health-based criteria.
When a product is issued a Gold Standard certification, it means it passed a very specific set of testing. A list of chemicals that Greenguard tests for in products can be found here.
Remember: Keeping all of these tips in mind, it does not mean that you have to break the bank to buy a new crib mattress.
There are always coupons, discounts and deals that can help you find the mattress you are looking for at a price that suits your budget.
Coupons and Deals
Sealy crib mattresses are relatively affordable, as far as crib mattresses go, and start at about $90.
If you are looking for a great deal, you can start by checking out the Sealy crib mattresses on Amazon.
Here, you can take advantage of free Amazon Prime shipping, as well as discounted rates for certain models.
You can also check out other retailers to see if there are any discounts offered directly through that retailer by being a rewards member, such as Target or Sears.
During the Spring and Fall seasons, many retailers order more mattresses than they need to sell in anticipation for a large influx of purchases.
This means that if they have an overstock of items, they will offer overstock sales and pricing.
New store openings and end of the year sales are another great time to act on mattress sales.
Otherwise, the best time to buy a mattress is typically during holiday sales that happen, such as Thanksgiving, Memorial Day, 4th of July, Christmas, and more.
What We Recommend
We highly recommend trying out the Sealy Crib Mattress line for your baby because of its high-quality mattresses, attention to detail, and their prioritization on health and safety.
Sealy goes the extra mile to make sure their products meet all safety requirements and display all important features for each of their products.
Consider your overall budget, as well as which features are most important to you. You can also talk to your baby’s doctor or pediatrician for advice on what to consider when starting your search for the perfect crib mattress.
Parents can have peace of mind knowing that no matter which crib mattress they choose from the Sealy line, their baby will be comfortable and secure throughout their use of the mattress in the crib and in their transition to a toddler bed.