Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress Review

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress Review

Are you a parent looking for a mattress for your baby’s crib before the big day comes? Maybe you’re a proud grandparent or friend looking for the perfect baby shower gift.

Then again, you may just be researching for a friend or dreaming about the future. There’s nothing wrong with being extra prepared, since choosing the proper mattress is one of the most important decisions to make as a new parent.

Whatever the case may be, we’re glad you’re here and we’ve got you covered with this review of the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress!

Some Background on the Safety 1st Brand

If you have been driving for a while, you’ve probably known the Safety 1st brand for some time now.

Remember the yellow “BABY ON BOARD!” sign you’ve seen attached to the back windshield of certain vehicles? Safety 1st has been manufacturing the product since 1984, providing proud parents with a functional way to announce they have recently joined the parenting “club” for over 30 years.

Throughout their years in the market, Safety 1st has become a leading brand in child safety products, expanding product lines to include a myriad of home and travel safety products for children. Their success has allowed them to further diversify into other product categories, including mattresses.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

What You Should Know About the Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress

There are plenty of choices on the market when it comes to purchasing a new crib mattress for your baby, especially because many mattresses share common characteristics.

The Heavenly Dreams Mattress has a unique combination of traits:

Greenguard Gold Certified Mattress

Holding a Greenguard Gold Certification means that the certified product has met rigorous standards, with low measurements in chemical emissions.

The fact that Safety 1st holds this certification for the Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress tells us they are invested in providing a product that will protect you and your family’s health.

Light as a Feather Construction and Budget-friendly Price Point

The Heavenly Dreams Mattress is constructed out of high-density thermo-bonded fiber core made from polyester. It also features a polypropylene laminate.

With this construction, you’ll get a durable and firm, yet lightweight product – weighing in at manageable 7.5 pounds – allowing you to easily place this mattress in your baby’s crib.

You will also be able to take it out of the crib often for regular cleaning.

You’ll find this product at prices ranging from $42 to $76. What’s best, this mattress can stay with your child as he or she grows into a preschooler, turning into a toddler mattress once the crib is no longer necessary.

baby yawning in bed

Vinyl Mattress Cover

The fully removable, machine washable outer cover made from 100% vinyl will make cleaning a breeze. Since it is made out of hypoallergenic vinyl, it will fight the growth of bacteria, minimize the effects of dust mites, and help reduce allergy symptoms.

The construction of the mattress cover resists wearing and tearing, meaning your child could use it into the preschool years.

It is also stain resistant, odor resistant, and water resistant, making for extremely easy cleanup of spills.

How the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress Compares to 3 Other Baby Mattresses

While a baby mattress isn’t a product you’ll need to last for dozens of years, it is always best to comparison shop to make sure you get the best value for your money.

Here are three comparable products on the market you may want to check out:

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress for Baby & Toddler, Water Resistant, Lightweight, Hypoallergenic, Green Guard Gold Certified
  • NOTE: Item model# 5805096 is the same item as model# BM204. There was a change to the model number for manufacturer internal purposes. Actual item is same
  • Lightweight and durable. It is made with high density thermo-bonded fiber core that provides firm support and a 100% Vinyl outer cover that is water resistant and wipes clean.
  • Mattress dimensions: 52"L x 27.5"W x 5"H. Weight limit: 50 lb. For optimal use, rotate mattress every 2-3 months. 10-year limited warranty. Assembled in Canada.
  • This mattress has achieved GREENGUARD GOLD Certification. GREENGUARD Certified products are certified to GREENGUARD standards for low chemical emissions into indoor air during product usage.Free of phthalates and lead
  • Fits standard crib with internal measurements of 28⅝ in. X 53 in. ;5" thickness extra firm mattress

Just to make sure we’re comparing fairly, here’s a summary of the Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress features:

  • Warranty: 5-year limited warranty.
  • Certification: Greenguard Gold.
  • Construction: The 5-inch mattress features a foam construction, described above.
  • Mattress Dimensions, Weight & Weight Limit: 52 inches long/27.5 inches wide/ 5 inches deep/7.5 lbs/50 lbs.
  • Firmness: Firm for baby. Does not include dual firmness.
  • Configuration Options: Available in three colors: white, pink, and blue.
  • Mattress Cover: 100% vinyl resists odors, stains, and water.
  • Rating on Amazon: 4 stars.
  • Pricing: Ranging from $54 to $65.

It may be hard to be an award-winning baby product brand, but let’s see what other similar products have to offer.

Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress, Twilight
  • Mattress is proudly constructed of quality materials and workmanship in the USA
  • Mattress Meets Federal Standard Flammability Standard 16-CFR 1633. All Dream on Me mattresses are GREENGUARD Gold Certified for a healthy indoor environment for your baby.
  • Fits all standard size cribs and toddler beds for years of use ;Offers a protective polyurethane foam wrap on each side delivers a plush sleeping surface
  • Features include a hypo-allergenic, foam Insulating layer and lock-stitched waterproof binding for lasting durability and a layer of Fire blocker.
  • 30 Day Warranty

Like Safety 1st, the Dream On Me baby product brand is not a mattress-only manufacturer. There is limited information about this product online, but it does have over 1000 reviews on Amazon, 60% of which are 5-star reviews.

  • Warranty: 10-year limited warranty.
  • Certification: Greenguard Gold.
  • Construction: The 5-inch mattress features an 80-coil construction with antibacterial, waterproof lock stitched binding. It also includes “breathe-flow material on the infant side and a waterproof cover on the toddler side” as described on the manufacturer website.
  • Mattress Dimensions, Weight & Weight Limit: 51.5 inches long/27.5 inches wide/ 5 inches deep/12 lbs/Information not available.
  • Firmness: Firm for baby. Does not include dual firmness.
  • Configuration Options: None.
  • Mattress Cover: None included, but the mattress is double-sided with a brown cloud pattern on one side and bright white on the other.
  • Rating on Amazon: 4 stars.
  • Pricing: Ranging from $43 to $53.

Overall, this is a comparable option from a brand recognized for one of their cribs in 2018 by Baby Center’s Mom’s Picks.

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress with Waterproof Cover - 27.5 inches x 52 inches x 4.75 inches
  • The Milliard Crib Mattress uses a unique blend of foam to create the perfect combination of comfort, and the firmness recommended for babies and toddlers.
  • Say goodbye to uncomfortable spring mattresses and cheap quality synthetic blends.
  • The reinforced mattress encasement is waterproof on the top and sides, but allows air and heat to ventilate on the bottom. The encasement backside is made from anti-flame materials without any chemicals.
  • Milliard foam supersedes all with superior high density construction that will not lose its shape.
  • Milliard Foam is CertiPUR-US certified. Measures: 52" x 27.5" x 4.75".

The Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress has been reviewed by over 1200 consumers on, with 60% of the reviews rated at 5 stars.

  • Warranty: Information not readily available. The manufacturer’s website references a return policy that requires the customer to ship back the items at their own expense.
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US.
  • Construction: The 5.5-inch mattress features a memory foam construction.
  • Mattress Dimensions, Weight & Weight Limit: 52 inches long/27.5 inches wide/ 5.5 inches deep/9.8 lbs/NA.
  • Firmness: Medium Firm for baby. Does not include dual firmness.
  • Configuration Options: None.
  • Mattress Cover: The cover is waterproof on the top and sides. The reverse is made from anti-flame materials without any chemicals which allows air and heat to ventilate on the bottom.
  • Rating on Amazon: 4.5 stars.
  • Pricing: Ranging from $54 to $59.

The Milliard Bedding brand is a part of the Milliard family of brands. While they do have a dedicated website to their bedding products, Milliard relies heavily on selling their products via Amazon.

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Orthopedic Style Crib Mattress | Eco-Friendly Foam with Ultra-Soft Organic Waterproof Hypoallergenic Cotton Cover - 51.63" x 27.25" x 6"
  • 6" THICK ORTHOPEDIC MATTRESS - The Eco Classica III is a standard size orthopedic lightweight Crib mattress designed for most standard American cribs and toddler beds. The Crib mattress is approximately 51.63" long, 27.25" wide and 6" thick. Please measure your Crib or bed before purchasing
  • DUAL-FIRMNESS - The extra firm side is engineered to provide the firmness infants need for proper support and development, while the less firm side provides the comfort toddlers prefer
  • ULTRA-SOFT WATERPROOF COVER - The eco-friendly crib and toddler mattress is wrapped snugly inside an ultra-soft certified organic cotton cover, which is waterproof-backed to ensure the mattress stays dry while the baby's skin remains closest to organic cotton
  • GREENGUARD GOLD & CertiPUR-US CERTIFIED - Like all Colgate mattresses, The Eco Classica III is GREENGUARD Gold, and CertiPUR-US certified, CPSIA compliant, and compliant with all federal and state flammability requirements - without the use of Fire retardant chemicals
  • MADE IN THE USA - The Eco Classica III is designed to last throughout the infant and toddler years, with inverted seams to ensure Mattress durability. All Colgate Crib mattresses are proudly handcrafted in the USA by Colgate, The Crib mattress Specialist, a family-owned and operated business dedicated to baby's safety since 1955
The brand Colgate self identifies as “the crib mattress specialist,” and they have been operating since 1955 and have multiple industry awards to show for their efforts to serve and protect babies with their products.
  • Warranty: Colgate offers a life-time warranty to customers who are the original purchaser of one of their products direct via the manufacturer website.
  • Certification: Greenguard Gold & CertiPUR-US.
  • Construction: The 6-inch mattress features a dual-firmness foam construction.
  • Mattress Dimensions, Weight & Weight Limit: 51.7 inches long/27.5 inches wide/ 6 inches deep/9.44 lbs/NA.
  • Firmness: Firm for baby and less firm for toddlers.
  • Configuration Options: None.
  • Mattress Cover: Waterproof and food grade.
  • Rating on Amazon: 4.4 stars.
  • Pricing: Ranging from $174 to $220

While multiple awards may be hard to ignore, there’s significantly less information coming directly from consumers on this mattress. It may help to know what parents who have experience using the Heavenly Dreams Mattress have to say.

What Are People Saying About Safety 1st’s Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress? 

Knowing what other consumers have to say about a product is a great way to help guide purchasing decisions.

When it comes to your child’s mattress – especially one you will use in your child’s crib – it’s important to know what people experienced when they received their product and how they went about setting it up in their home.

On Amazon, this product is rated at four stars, with 65% of reviewers having given the Heavenly Dreams mattress a five-star rating. That’s over 2000 reviews putting their vote 100% behind the product.

Safety 1st Wins Women’s Choice Award for 2017

In 2017, Safety 1st received the Women’s Choice Award as America’s Most Recommended Brand for Crib & Toddler Mattresses. This means that Safety 1st has been vetted by women in your community and across the country as a brand they most respect and trust for this product type in particular.

According to Delia Passi, Founder and Chief Mission Officer, when a product bears the Women’s Choice Award seal, it can help women to make purchasing decision confidently – assured that the product is back by “the collective voice of women.”

What Parents Love About the Heavenly Dreams Mattress

Consumers love that this mattress fits into their budgets as new parents and that their child will be able to use the product well into their pre-school years. They love how the product is lightweight and easy to clean.

One fellow reviewer boasted about the packaging which – in true Safety 1st style – provides documentation about the product certifications and specifications as soon as you get the package open.

The trustworthiness of the brand is a big determiner for consumers when they decide to purchase the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress.

What Parents Could Do Without

Since the cover is made of vinyl, it feels like plastic to the touch. This quality can have certain undesirable traits.

For example, some parents complain that the mattress is noisy. Others complain that that the mattress is not very breathable. This could contribute to heat retention on the mattress, making for a very uncomfortable nap or night’s sleep for your child.

In addition, some other parents have reported a deteriorating mattress, with pieces of foam coming apart that could pose as a choking hazard for your child.

baby sleeping in crib mattress

What We Think About the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

All in all, we think the Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is an excellent product and sound investment, and we do recommend it.

As far as safety goes, the product is so well-constructed, that inexperienced parents may not even know to notice.

Here are some examples of small details Safety 1st takes care of in manufacturing the Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress that we thought you should know about:

  • Firm Mattress: The firm support the thermo-bonded 5-inch thick construction provides means the child will be safeguarded against any accidents involving the child sinking into the mattress.
  • Mattress Size: Heavenly dreams is the correct size for standard cribs, which means that baby will not risk getting trapped in any gaps between the edge of the mattress and the crib.
  • Squared Corners: Square corners on a mattress will also ensure the mattress fits snugly into the crib or toddler bed, preventing gaps around the bed that could allow arms or small heads to slip through.
  • Support Along the Mattress Edge: Since you’ll keep this mattress through to when your child begins walking, it is very important that the mattress is reinforced along the edges. When baby begins to stand up in her crib, she will need that support to avoid slips and injuries.
  • Quality Seam and Zipper Construction: Loose thread in a mattress could pose a risk for baby or toddler, so the fact that Safety 1st has assured the manufacture of the vinyl cover follows strict quality standards is yet another point in favor of the Heavenly Dreams mattress.
  • Along with the above guidelines, you may want to check out the Safe to Sleep campaign led by the National Institute of Health. It is a great resource to learn about essential safety guidelines to keep children safe as they sleep.
  • Even if you decide against this particular brand and product, we encourage you to take the above requirements and recommendations into account when buying your child’s first mattress. We also advise using them to regularly monitor the integrity of any baby mattress while it is in use.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here